Hard times lure Afghans to Iran, deter some refugees from returning
Every year, hundreds of thousands of Afghans head to Iran in search of work, saying their strife-torn country cannot provide enough suitable jobs.
KABUL, Afghanistan, August 11 (UNHCR) - On most weekdays a long queue of people stretches down the pavement outside the Iranian Embassy in Kabul, located opposite the UNHCR office in the Afghan capital. The wait can easily last hours, even days, and many come away disappointed.
The hundreds of people queuing are in search of work. Many of them are former refugees who have returned home from camps in Pakistan or Iran since the fall of the Taliban in 2001. The scarcity of jobs in Afghanistan is not only convincing young men to look for work elsewhere; it is also deterring many refugees from returning home.
"I'm waiting for my Iranian visa," said 23-year-old Qurban Ali. "I want to go to Mashhad [in north-east Iran] for a pilgrimage, to visit friends and to look for a job to support my family in Kabul."
Nearby, a man called Reza was getting increasingly frustrated with the long wait. "One of the areas which has seen the least development in Afghanistan [since 2001] is the creation of job opportunities," he complained. "This has forced thousands of young Afghans to look for jobs outside the country."
A recent study commissioned by UNHCR and funded by the European Commission says high unemployment, low wages and widespread poverty in Afghanistan are major factors pushing single men to migrate to Iran in search of work. Average wages in Iran are four times those in Afghanistan, according to the study, carried out by Kabul-based Altai Consulting.
"Repatriation has increased Afghanistan's population by an estimated 20 percent since 2002, a huge and rapid increase for any poor, developing country," said Ewen Macleod, UNHCR Representative in Afghanistan. "Employment will continue to be a major and important challenge for all Afghans, especially the young generation".
Three decades of conflict have left Afghanistan with serious socio-economic challenges. Many Afghan refugees in Iran and Pakistan considering repatriation say the lack of jobs and basic services makes their decision difficult. Refugees who have returned - as well as Afghan citizens who never left their homeland - struggle to survive.
Deputy Minister of Labour and Social Affairs Wasel Noor Mohammand said that more than 325,000 people had sought help from his ministry in finding employment, but only some 55,000 had found work in the government and private sectors. "Efforts to find jobs for the remaining applicants are ongoing," he said.
"The problem in finding jobs is the lack of skilled labour and computer knowledge among Afghan job seekers, who are mostly daily wage workers and illiterate," explained economic analyst Ustad Massoud, a professor at Kabul University.
The result is many Afghans look elsewhere for work. Some go to Pakistan as seasonal labourers while others go to Iran. The vast majority of them move back and forth irregularly and without documents.
In Iran, Afghan migrants and refugees work mostly in the construction and agriculture sectors. They often take jobs that Iranians don't want, and offer a reliable source of cheap labour. Their remittances - estimated at some US$500 million per year- help to support their families and villages.
"The movement of Afghans to and from Afghanistan is not a new phenomenon," said Abdul Karim Brahawi, the Afghan minister of refugees and repatriation.
However, he noted, "Now we have to look at the phenomenon from a different angle than the refugee perspective. It's essentially economic migration."
Since 1979, millions of Afghan refugees have sought safety mostly in Pakistan and Iran. Since 2001, some 850,000 Afghans refugees have returned from Iran with UNHCR's help. A further 1 million registered Afghan refugees remain in the country.
Meanwhile, the queues outside the Iranian embassy show no sign of shrinking. Mujtaba, an ethnic Hazara from Bamiyan in Afghanistan's central highlands, wants to work in Iran because he has a fiancé but cannot afford to get married.
"My elder brother and several of his friends went to Iran last year and earned enough money to get married," he said. "His standard of living has encouraged me to go to Iran and make enough to pay for my wedding and support my family here."
By Mohammad Nader Farhad
In Kabul, Afghanistan
Related news and stories
Entrepreneurship training helps Venezuelan refugees find stability
Women-run businesses in Afghanistan dealt a blow by deepening restrictions
UNHCR launches new appeal for Afghan refugees and hosts, urging partners to stay the course
I had to flee for my education, but refused to leave other Afghan girls to their fate
'Network Guardians' help to bridge gender digital gap in Ecuadorian neighbourhood
Former refugee, now volunteer teacher, helps other Afghan girls get an education
-
How to advocate for scholarships for refugees at your school or university
2022 Stand up, speak out, and advocate for scholarships for refugees -
Evaluation of the caring for refugees with non-communicable diseases project
31 Dec 2021 This evaluation (full report) assesses the relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact and sustainability of a capacity-building project, entitled "Caring for Refugees with Non-communicable diseases Project". The project aimed to improve the quality of non-communicable diseases care for refugees in UNHCR's care. The findings of the evaluation will be used to support learning and accountability; to guide programme practices to improve non-communicable diseases care in refugee operations; and to document lessons learned from implementation and field practice. Attachments: Executive Summary and Management Response (.zip) -
Evaluation of UNHCR's Child Protection Programming 2017-2019
31 Dec 2021 This evaluation reviewed the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees' child protection response in terms of its leadership role, strategies and programme performance with the purpose of informing the future of both UNHCR's child protection strategy and the implementation of UNHCR child protection programming. Attachments: Management Response Child Protection evaluation (.pdf) -
ES/2021/09 Evaluation of the Somos Panas Colombia Communication Campaign
31 Dec 2021 UNHCR in Colombia developed the Somos Panas ("We Are Buddies") Campaign to discourage expressions of xenophobia and promote empathy and solidarity towards Venezuelans to the benefit of society. This evaluation report evaluated the entire campaign and provides recommendations to improve actions during the next campaign cycle. Attachments: ES/2020/01 Executive Summary, Spanish version and Management Response (.zip) -
ES/2021/10 Evaluation of the project "Saving Maternal and Newborn Lives in Refugee Situations" in Cameroon, Chad and Niger.
31 Dec 2021 The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) commissioned this evaluation for the purpose of accountability and learning to inform future similar interventions. It examines the relevance, effectiveness and sustainability of the UNHCR and Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) project: "Saving maternal and newborn lives in refugee situations", implemented in three refugee operations in Chad, Niger and Cameroon between April 2018 and December 2019. Attachments: UNHCR Evaluation Management Response (.pdf) -
ES/2021/11 Mid-Term Process Evaluation of the IKEA Foundation Livelihoods and Energy Projects Among Somali Refugees and Host Communities in Ethiopia
31 Dec 2021 This decentralised mid-term process evaluation of Phase 3 (2019-21) of the IKEA Foundation- funded livelihoods and energy investment among the Somali refugees and host community was commissioned by the UNHCR Ethiopia/Melkadida sub-office (SOMEL). The purpose of the evaluation was to gauge the follow-up on baseline recommendations and assess the progress made toward creating sustainable livelihoods and fostering economic inclusion for refugees and their hosts in this region. Attachments: UNHCR Evaluation Management Response (.pdf) -
Evaluation Service - COVID-19 Evaluative Evidence Brief No 1
28 Dec 2021 To support organizational learning, UNHCR's Evaluation Service has commissioned an Evaluative Synthesis of UNHCR's adaptation and response to the COVID-19 pandemic. The purpose of the synthesis is to provide robust and timely evidence to UNHCR on how effectively the organisation has adapted to COVID-19 and to highlight areas of strength as well as the challenges emerging from across our evaluations. -
UNHCR regrets loss of life in the Aegean Sea, with at least 31 dead and more missing
28 Dec 2021 -
Amid surge in arrivals from Venezuela, UNHCR steps up response in the north of Chile
23 Dec 2021